How we choose
How Brand Identity Desk builds each guide
Each guide ranks 7 to 10 branding agencies for one kind of business. This page explains what goes into a ranking, where the facts come from, what each entry tells you and how the guides are kept current.
Why the guides exist
A rebrand is one of the larger marketing decisions a company makes, and agency directories often list hundreds of firms with little to separate them. Each guide narrows that field to the agencies with published brand strategy and visual identity work for one kind of business, and says plainly what each one does best.
What a guide is
Each guide names 7 to 10 branding agencies for one kind of business. For every agency it says what the agency is known for, why it made the list, the work that shows it, and one thing worth knowing before you hire it.
Who the guides are for
The guides are written for marketing leaders and founders planning a rebrand, a new brand identity or a brand refresh. Each guide covers one kind of business, such as B2B, SaaS or consumer goods, since the agency that suits a heritage consumer brand usually isn’t the one for a fast-growing software company.
What every guide is judged on
01
Brand work in the industry
Named case studies on the agency’s own site for companies in the guide’s industry. A case study only counts if we can open and read it.
02
Strategy behind the identity
Positioning, naming, brand architecture and messaging work published alongside the finished visual identity.
03
Fit for the moment
How well the work matches the situation the guide covers, such as a leadership change, a merger, a product launch or a move into new markets.
04
How far the work reaches
Whether the brand carries past the logo into the website, packaging, campaigns and brand guidelines.
What we check about each agency
01
The work itself
Identity systems, rebrands and campaigns the agency has published, especially in the industry the list covers.
02
Named clients
Clients an agency names on its own site, so the work can be checked.
03
Verified facts
Founding year and team size, checked against the agency’s site and press coverage. A blank field means we couldn’t confirm it.
How a guide is put together
01
Build the long list
We start with branding agencies that publish brand strategy and identity work for companies in the industry, found through their own case studies and client lists.
02
Review the work
We look at identity systems, rebrands and brand guidelines, and drop agencies whose recent work in that industry can’t be found.
03
Confirm the facts
Founding year, headquarters and team size are checked against each agency’s site and public records.
04
Rank the guide
The 7 to 10 agencies left are ordered by how well their brand strategy, identity and design work fits that kind of business.
Where the facts come from
Agency facts come from each agency’s own website first, then from press coverage and public records. We don’t use star ratings from review platforms. When a fact can’t be confirmed, the field is left blank.
What each entry tells you
Every agency in a guide gets the same fields: what it’s known for, who it’s best for, the services it covers, notable clients, the work that earned its place and the founding year and team size where we could confirm them. Each entry also says who should shortlist the agency, so you can rule firms out as quickly as you rule them in.
How guides stay current
Every guide shows the date it was last updated. We revise a guide when an agency’s facts change, such as a merger or a closure, or when a reader sends a correction we can confirm.
What a guide can’t tell you
A guide is a starting point. Rebrand budgets and timelines vary from project to project, so talk to two or three agencies and ask to see brand identity work like yours before you sign.
Corrections